0
By clicking the button, I accept the Terms of Use of the service and its Privacy Policy, as well as consent to the processing of personal data
Don’t have an account? Signup
Follow Us
High Court Ruling: PIAB Authorisation Required for Data Breach Personal Injury Claims
In a precedent-setting decision, the High Court has established a vital legal requirement for individuals seeking damages for personal injuries resulting from data breaches. This ruling, centered around the case of former Census Enumerator Siobhan Keane, underscores the necessity of obtaining Personal Injuries Assessment Board (PIAB) authorisation before initiating legal proceedings. Keane’s pursuit of damages, following an alleged unlawful disclosure of her personal data by the Central Statistics Office (CSO), highlights the complexities of seeking redress in the digital age.
Siobhan Keane’s legal journey began after her personal data, entrusted to the CSO for employment purposes in 2016, was purportedly shared with third parties without her consent in 2017. Claiming this breach inflicted severe stress, anxiety, and exacerbated her psoriatic arthritis, Keane sought compensation for her suffering. However, the Circuit Court’s initial ruling pinpointed a crucial misstep in her approach: the absence of a PIAB authorisation, a procedural prerequisite for such claims. This oversight, as per Judge Simon McAleese’s assessment, essentially nullified her primary claim for damages, confining potential compensation to non-material damages under GDPR Article 82 and section 117 of the Data Protection Act 2018, from which she ultimately received no award.
The High Court’s affirmation of the Circuit Court’s decision on appeal serves as a significant reminder of the legal intricacies involved in data breach cases. It delineates a clear procedural path for potential claimants, emphasizing the importance of securing a PIAB authorisation as a fundamental step in pursuing personal injury claims arising from data breaches. This ruling not only impacts future claimants but also sends a message to legal practitioners about the critical importance of adhering to procedural requirements in such cases.
This landmark ruling may have far-reaching effects, potentially setting a precedent for how personal injury claims stemming from data breaches are handled in Ireland. As digital data becomes increasingly integral to our personal and professional lives, the intersection of data protection laws and personal injury law will likely become a more prominent battleground for legal disputes. This case, Siobhan Keane vs. Central Statistics Office, thus not only brings to light the specific requirements for such claims but also opens up broader discussions about privacy rights, data protection, and the legal frameworks needed to safeguard individuals in a digital world.
As the legal community and potential claimants navigate this evolving landscape, the importance of understanding and adhering to the procedural prerequisites for litigation in cases of personal injury resulting from data breaches has never been more critical. The High Court’s decision in this case marks an important step in defining those boundaries and responsibilities, shaping the future of personal injury and data protection litigation in Ireland.
Subscribe to our Newsletter!
Share this article
If you liked this article share it with your friends.
they will thank you later
